It is thanks to each and every one of you that has made Generasia the largest resource for Asian media info. To our wonderful contributors, thank you!


From generasia
(Redirected from Talk:Kim Jae Joong)
Jump to: navigation, search

Any reason the bio/trivia was removed? Was it copied from someplace like Wikipedia?

Sorry, I asked Themonkeyofdoom about this and I didn't get a response. I thought it was ok to remove it. As I said to Themonkeyofdoom all that trivia made look the page as a fan-site or something like that. I don't think this is the place for things like when he got his first kiss or things like "Feels that Japanese Curry mixes really well with rice". If I remember correctly back in ThePPN all the biased comments or unnecessary fandom info were quickly removed.--Pizca 21:14, 27 February 2010 (UTC)
Oh, about the bio, what I deleted was basically more trivia in a paragraph.--Pizca 21:17, 27 February 2010 (UTC)
Pizca, I just replied lol, sorry for the wait. Well I know that the original thePPN article was written by a user whom has aksed us not to use her work. I also feel that most of that "Trivia" was just useless fangirl ranting and doesn't hold any importance. ~ Themonkeyofdoom 21:18, 27 February 2010 (UTC)
That's fine then. Just wasn't sure of the reason and now I know. One thing I mentioned months ago that I'm not sure can be done (I should probably put this on the forum) is have the artist pages cover not just artist releases, but also things like magazine and TV appearances,etc. It was done with Ayumi, and I realize it'd be a bit time-consuming to do that, but I know that even Wikipedia doesn't track these things for artists. I guess I'm just hoping things can be as comprehensive as possible, so it's no worries if trivias aren't always kept for artists. --EXodius 21:48, 27 February 2010 (UTC)
I don't think a list of performance should be placed on an artists page. Could you image a list of Hamasaki Ayumi's performance all on her main page? It would be way too long. I like the current format we have of the performance dates on the release/song pages. I also don't really see any importance in a page like this. I also feel like if we start making pages like this for every artist, it's gonna be another H!P culsterfuck, with the H!P on Music Fighter, H!P on ASAYLAN, H!P on Music Station pages, which are all just un-need. ~ Themonkeyofdoom 22:31, 27 February 2010 (UTC)
Seeing as how there have been over 400 views (of course some people edited the page several times) for that magazine page, obviously some people use it. What I feel is that the wiki can go beyond the music discographies. When I suggested performances, I didn't mean the artist page listing every single one. As you said, having the performances listed in the song/release pages is fine. I would just simply want that extended out to not just Ayu but other artists. There have been countless times when I ask myself something like "I wonder how many times X artist performed X song and when they did it", so getting this done for other songs would be nice. However, it's just my opinion :) --EXodius 06:06, 28 February 2010 (UTC)
Oh, OK lol. Sorry, I thought you wanted to start creating a bunch of extra pages. The TV performances are being placed on more than just Hamasaki's pages. I've found it hard to find the performance dates for older performance, you can find a lot of them on YouTube, but the often don't have the date. ~ Themonkeyofdoom 11:13, 28 February 2010 (UTC)
There are no threads on this page yet.